When Buying Miles on American Makes More Cents

November 2009
Read Offline

Here’s an interesting fact about American on domestic routes: Its First Class mileage upgrade inventory uses the same booking code (A) as its lowest discounted First Class seats. Most often, an airline puts these seats in separate “buckets” with the upgrade bucket being, by far, the smaller of the two.

In a random search among AA’s domestic routes, we found that, in every case, the number of discount First Class seats available on a flight matched the number of upgrade seats. That means American is giving you more access to First Class upgrades than most other airlines. (See chart, bottom right, for sample upgrade availability.)

Best of all, you can save up to 50% by using this strategy: Book your seat with a mileage upgrade instead of buying a discount First Class ticket. Even with no miles in your account, you can buy all you need and still realize huge savings (see chart, above right). Domestic upgrades require 30,000 miles round-trip (at a cost of $750 plus taxes), a $30 transaction fee, and, starting Dec. 1, a $150 round-trip co-pay.

American’s annual purchase limit is 40,000 miles. If you have Starwood or Diners Club points, you can transfer them to American.

[table_opt style="gray-header" id="1529" width="" alignment="center" responsive="all" heading="thcenter" rows="tdcenter"]

[table_opt style="gray-header" id="1530" width="" alignment="center" responsive="all" heading="thcenter" rows="tdcenter"]

[["<strong>Route<\/strong>","<strong>Lowest Upgradeable Economy Fare<\/strong>","<strong>Total Including Cost to Buy Miles and Co-pay<\/strong>","<strong>Lowest First Class Fare<\/strong>","<strong>Savings<\/strong>"],["Boston - Chicago","$188","$1,088 ","$1,624 ","$536 \/ 33%"],["Boston - Dallas","$355","$1,255 ","$2,024 ","$769 \/ 38%"],["Chicago - Los Angeles","$268","$1,168 ","$2,082 ","$914 \/ 44%"],["Chicago - San Francisco","$250","$1,150 ","$2,152 ","$1,002 \/ 47%"],["Dallas - Detroit","$238","$1,088 ","$1,542 ","$454 \/ 29%"],["Dallas - Miami","$254","$1,154 ","$1,524 ","$370 \/ 24%"],["Dallas - Washington, DC ","$228","$1,128 ","$2,084 ","$956 \/ 46%"],["Los Angeles - Boston","$218","$1,118 ","$2,164 ","$1,046 \/ 48%"],["Los Angeles - Dallas","$268","$1,168 ","$1,624 ","$456 \/ 28%"],["Miami - Los Angeles","$278","$1,178 ","$1,844 ","$666 \/ 36%"],["San Francisco - Dallas","$288","$1,188 ","$1,672 ","$484 \/ 29%"],["San Francisco - New York","$218","$1,118 ","$2,224 ","$1,106 \/ 50%"]]
<small><em>Base fares, not including taxes. </em></small>
[["<strong>Route<\/strong>","<strong>Availability<\/strong>"],["Boston - Chicago","Plentiful both directions Nov.- Aug."],["Boston - Dallas","Plentiful both directions Nov.- Aug."],["Chicago - Los Angeles","Plentiful both directions except Dec. holiday dates outbound, and Nov. holiday dates on the return."],["Chicago - San Francisco","Plentiful except between second week in Nov to second week in December, both directions."],["Dallas - Detroit","Plentiful both directions Nov.- Aug."],["Dallas - Miami","Plentiful both directions Dec.- Aug."],["Dallas - Washington D.C.","Plentiful both directions Nov.- Aug."],["Los Angeles - Boston","Plentiful outbound from second week in Jan. - Aug. Avoid Nov. & Dec. holiday dates on the return."],["Los Angeles - Dallas","Plentiful both directions Nov.- Aug."],["Miami - Los Angeles","Plentiful both directions Feb.- Aug. Nov. - Jan. scattered dates getting slim. Avoid holiday dates."],["San Francisco - Dallas","Plentiful both directions Nov.- Aug."],["San Francisco - New York","Plentiful both directions Jan. - Aug. Avoid holiday dates."]]